Header graphic for print
Florida Banking Law Blog Legal developments impacting banking, finance and loan enforcement in Florida

J. Ellsworth Summers, Jr.

J. Ellsworth Summers practices primarily in bankruptcy and commercial litigation, representing secured and unsecured creditors and committees. Mr. Summers also has extensive experience with workouts and other business reorganizations. Prior to private practice, Mr. Summers clerked for the Honorable Stephen C. St. John, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge for the Eastern District of Virginia.

Posts by J. Ellsworth Summers, Jr.

Holder of Equity Interest in Bankrupt Company not Entitled to Become Shareholder in Reorganized Entity

Posted in Bankruptcy

A recent Eleventh Circuit case examines equity shareholders’ role (or lack thereof) in a reorganized entity.  Vision-Park Properties owned an equity share of Seaside Engineering & Surveying, Inc.  Seaside filed for Chapter 11 protection in 2011, and shortly thereafter proposed to reorganize and continue operations as Gulf Atlantic, LLC. According to the proposed Chapter 11… Continue Reading

Two Sides of the Same Coin: Chapter 11 Reform in the House and Senate

Posted in Bankruptcy

As we discussed in our previous post, in the wake of the financial crisis that began with large financial institutions failing in 2008, practitioners and politicians alike have been calling for Bankruptcy Code reform.  Both the U.S. House and Senate have proposed solutions, yet with the recent midterm election results, the future of these two… Continue Reading

Commission Calls for Overhaul of Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Code

Posted in Bankruptcy

On Monday, December 8, 2014, the American Bankruptcy Institute’s Chapter 11 Reform Commission, which is tasked with recommending reforms to the nearly 40-year-old bankruptcy regime, released a report which found that the current Chapter 11 system has fallen behind the times.  The Commission’s report urges Congress to provide troubled businesses with a better chance at… Continue Reading

Ms. McNeal Goes to Washington

Posted in Bankruptcy

For those of you who have followed our blog since its inception, you will know that one of our most discussed opinions is that of In re McNeal, in which the Eleventh Circuit held that a debtor may strip a wholly unsecured junior mortgage in a Chapter 7 proceeding.  Although the decision is anathema to… Continue Reading

Written Document Retention and Destruction Policy Saves the Day (Again)

Posted in Debt and Judgment Collection

As we mentioned in our previous posts regarding document preservation, establishing a written document retention and destruction policy is essential to any company, large or small.  As with the Pradaxa case out of the Southern District of Illinois, a recent case out of the Northern District of New York, Research Foundation of SUNY v. Nektar… Continue Reading

Detroit Bankruptcy Update: Settlements and Feasibility

Posted in Bankruptcy, Debt and Judgment Collection

In Detroit’s ongoing restructuring effort, the city cleared a major hurdle last week by settling with its largest adversary, Syncora Guarantee, a New York based bond insurer.  The settlement was negotiated just a week into the bankruptcy trial and was so significant that Judge Steven Rhodes adjourned the trial for two days to allow the… Continue Reading

Non-Dischargeable Tax Debt Not Special Class of Unsecured Creditors

Posted in Bankruptcy, Debt and Judgment Collection

In numerous previous posts, we have noted that the purpose of the Bankruptcy Code is to help the “honest but unfortunate debtor.”  Like gerrymandering, certain “creative” debtors have attempted to classify their non-dischargeable debt as a separate, special class of unsecured creditors.  In a recent case out of the Eighth Circuit, In re Copeland, the… Continue Reading

Discharging the Brunner Test: Student Loan Debt in Bankruptcy

Posted in Bankruptcy

Twenty-seven years ago the Second Circuit was faced with a debtor who proposed to use the Bankruptcy Code to avoid her student loan debt – only five months after graduation.  The Second Circuit came down harshly on Ms. Brunner and established an “undue hardship” test, which few debtors have passed since the decision in the… Continue Reading

Detroit Bankruptcy Update: Restructuring the Restructuring Plan

Posted in Bankruptcy

On Friday July 25, 2014, the City of Detroit released a revised restructuring plan that provides for a reserve fund that may enhance the recovery for certain classes of unsecured creditors.  The plan also creates a post-bankruptcy “monitor” whose role and responsibility would be to evaluate the city’s ongoing compliance with the plan and confirmation… Continue Reading

Detroit Bankruptcy Update: Sixth Circuit Throws Wrench into Restructuring Timetable

Posted in Bankruptcy

Earlier this month the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the appeal of Syncora Guarantee Inc. must be heard by the lower federal district court before the bankruptcy court may conduct its trial on the city’s proposed Chapter 9 restructuring plan, which is scheduled to begin on August 14th.  Syncora, a municipal bond insurer… Continue Reading

Eleventh Circuit Doubles Down on Lien Stripping

Posted in Uncategorized

When the Fourth Circuit handed down its opinion in the case of In re Davis,[1] which permitted lien stripping in “Chapter 20” proceedings, the stage was set for the Eleventh Circuit to expand debtor’s ability to escape from underwater junior mortgages.  Before the June 18th opinion in In re Scantling,[2] bankruptcy courts within the Eleventh… Continue Reading

A Lesson on What Not to do in a § 363 Auction

Posted in Bankruptcy

For numerous corporate Chapter 11 debtors, the sale of some or all of the company’s assets may be the only way to reorganize the company’s debt.  Section 363 of the Bankruptcy Code provides the authority for a debtor to sell estate assets outside the normal course of the debtor’s business.  Oftentimes, a court establishes specific… Continue Reading

Supreme Court Clarifies Stern v. Marshall

Posted in Bankruptcy

Not even Nostradamus could have predicted the profound effect that former Playmate Vickie Lynn Marshall (a/k/a Anna Nicole Smith) would have on the landscape of U.S. bankruptcy court jurisdiction.  Nevertheless, two and a half years after the Supreme Court issued its opinion in Stern v. Marshall, questions remained as to what role a bankruptcy court… Continue Reading

Eleventh Circuit Holds Replacement Value – Applies to Surrender of Collateral in Chapter 13 Plan

Posted in Bankruptcy, Commercial Lending

On March 27, 2014, the Eleventh Circuit (the “Court”) issued a ruling, which will have a major impact on how Chapter 7 and 13 debtors are able to treat claims of secured creditors. The issue in In re Brown, 13-13013, 2014 WL 1245266 (11th Cir. 2014) was whether §506(a)(2)’s valuation standard, which requires use of… Continue Reading

Recent Decision Caps Secured Creditor’s Credit Bid in §363 Sale to Purchase Price of Acquired Debt

Posted in Bankruptcy, Commercial Lending

It is well-settled that secured creditors are ordinarily entitled to credit bid their allowed secured claim in a sale pursuant to § 363 of the Bankruptcy Code (the “Code”). In Radlax Gateway Hotel, LLC v. Amalgamated Bank, 132 S.Ct. 205 (2012), the Supreme Court acknowledged that bankruptcy courts have the power to prohibit a secured… Continue Reading

Caveat Debtor: Disgorging Inheritance in Chapter 13 Cases

Posted in Bankruptcy

A recent case out of the 9th Circuit, In re Dale, revives a controversial subject for Chapter 13 debtors: whether an inheritance received more than 180 days after commencement of the case is part of the bankruptcy estate.  Ultimately the 9th Circuit agreed with the 4th Circuit that while inheritance that debtor received more than… Continue Reading

Dirt-for-Debt Buries Creditor with Risk and Uncertainty

Posted in Bankruptcy, Commercial Lending

In order to confirm a chapter 11 plan of reorganization, a debtor must satisfy all the provisions of §1129(a) of the Bankruptcy Code, except for §1129(a)(8). Section (a)(8) requires that each class of creditors either (i) accepts the proposed plan or (ii) is unimpaired under the proposed plan. When a debtor fails to meet 1129(a)(8),… Continue Reading

Google Case Provides Spoliation Exception to Living Document Safeguard

Posted in Banking Operations

Google has come under scrutiny in the last few years over collecting information from users’ email accounts to provide targeted advertising for its paid clients. In a 2013 case filed in the Northern District of California, Keith Dunbar filed a class action lawsuit against the internet behemoth, alleging that Google had unlawfully and intentionally intercepted… Continue Reading